Public discontent after Knapdale Ward consultation

HSCP chief officer Joanna MacDonald addresses the meeting in Lochgilphead
HSCP chief officer Joanna MacDonald addresses the meeting in Lochgilphead

Want to read more?

We value our content, so access to our full site is  only available on subscription.

Your subscription entitles you to 7-day-a-week access to our website, plus a full digital copy of that week’s paper to read on your pc/mac or mobile device.

And there’s more – your subscription includes access to digital archive copies from 2006 onwards

Already a subscriber?


Subscribe Now

In the face of widespread opposition to plans to close the region’s only specialist dementia unit, health bosses faced the public at a lively consultation meeting in Lochgilphead.

A final decision is due to be made on the future of dementia care in Argyll and Bute – including the proposed closure of Knapdale Ward within Mid Argyll Hospital  – at the next meeting of the board governing the region’s health and social care services on Wednesday March 25.

The governing body, known as Argyll and Bute Integration Joint Board (IJB), will have in front of it that day a report based on the findings of the consultation.

A series of consultation meetings have been held across Argyll, with the Lochgilphead event held at the Baptist Church Hall on Tuesday March 10.

Senior staff from the region’s Health and Social Care Partnership (HSCP) gave a presentation on the plans for dementia care, followed by a question and answer session.

Four options have been considered by a dementia services review group commissioned by the HSCP, with the preferred option being to move to a community care model, with inpatient services provided ‘out of area’. Knapdale ward would be closed. Three community dementia teams would operate – one each in Mid Argyll, Kintyre and the Islands; Cowal and Bute; and Lorn and the Isles.

Speaking at the meeting, HSCP chief officer Joanna MacDonald said the planned changes were ‘not about saving money’, adding the money currently used to run Knapdale Ward would be diverted to enhanced community teams.

Mid Argyll Hospital
Mid Argyll Hospital

According to papers presented in January to the IJB, the ‘redesign’ would save an estimated £200,000 within Argyll and Bute – but if 10 patients per annum require inpatient care, the additional payment to NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde would potentially be £196,000.

Trade union UNISON, with the support of dementia patients’ relatives and NHS staff, has spearheaded calls for another of the options considered by the dementia services review group to be taken forward.

This alternative model – known as ‘Option Four’ – would develop Knapdale ward to provide inpatient assessment/respite/day care/outpatients/information hub and a community team base along with the development of enhanced community teams.

Option four would include the installation of dementia-friendly flooring; fitting out of a sensory room and resources to fund an improved activities programme; dementia appropriate toilet fittings; a proper sitting room with soft and period furnishings; more homely decor throughout; the filling of 3.5 RMN vacancies and the re-opening of the ward.

At the consultation meeting, a current Knapdale ward nurse said: ‘We take people in crisis dementia settings who might have violent tendencies or perhaps suffer from delusions. What is going to happen to these dementia patients? Care homes won’t look at them.’

Another member of the public, a former nurse, added: ‘You need support services for these community teams. You can’t have three teams working in isolation. Don’t throw the baby out with the bath water here.’

Amid the frustration being expressed by the public, Ardrishaig minister David Carruthers addressed the assembled senior HSCP managers: ‘You are talking here about engaging with the community,’ he said. ‘It’s a shame that did not happen before the recommendation went to the IJB in January. Part of what people are objecting to is the way this has been handled. There is no real discussion.’

The HSCP’s head of service for older adults and community hospitals, Caroline Cherry, was a leading member of the dementia services review group. As the consultation meeting closed she conceded: ‘What I’m hearing here today is that we haven’t really sold this decision.’

David Carruthers made a final appeal, posing the question: ‘Does the IJB have to make a decision at its next meeting?

‘The evidence from this meeting is that the decision must be postponed.’

Trade union UNISON is organising a march and rally on Saturday March 21 in support of saving and improving Knapdale Ward as part of enhanced dementia provision under Option Four.
The plan is to assemble 10.30am outside the Comraich Centre, Blairbuie Road, Lochgilphead, before marching at 11am to a rally on Lochgilphead front green.